Okay, so here's the deal: I'm in Dallas on business. I watched the Women Tell All without the benefit of a DVR, so I probably missed a few things. Also, I tend to zone out during the WTA, so I probably missed a little bit more because of that. And, I probably missed even more because I spent most of the episode wondering how quickly I could write this blog so I could get down to the hotel lobby and stalk the New York Knicks.
WHAT?!
Oh, yeah, the Knicks are staying at my hotel. Am I Knicks fan? No. But Joey Tribbiani is and I feel like I would be doing him a great disservice if I didn't put in some time at least
trying to hide behind a plant and take a picture of Jeremy Lin.
Of course, Joey Tribbiani has no clue who Jeremy Lin is because Joey would now be pushing 40 and Jeremy Lin, is, what? 14?
In fact, I think they are all 14. Because, last night I was at the desk checking in and I noticed a swarm of super tall guys in the lobby and I thought "I bet those guys play basketball." Then David said "What was with the basketball team in the lobby?" I said "I know, right?" (Even though I'm not supposed to say that.) "But they all looked soooo young. I bet it's a college team or something." Because, March Madness and such, right?
So, today I find out it was, in fact, the Knicks. I text David to tell him. (He was only in town for the weekend and headed back today.) He replies "I KNEW I SAW JEREMY LIN!!" Plus, considering Jeremy Lin is likely the only NBA player either of us can identify, this was extra exciting for him. (We're not NBA fans. Sue us.) Also, I'm officially ancient.
All that to say that I am far more interested in maybe seeing a glimpse of someone who might be a Knickerbocker than I am in Ben's "journey to find love"... but, alas, you don't come here for a recap the NBA.
So, Ben's ladies...
Chris, of course, tells us how this is THE MOST controversial season EVER. You know, because he big puffy hearts hyperbole. He also says that, for the first time ever, one of the final two ladies has come to the WTA to face the music.
But, before we can get to the gals, we have to find out where some former contestants are now.
Luckily, they are all in Vegas. Drinking heavily and grinding on one another. We see a few people making out. A few people dancing inappropriately. Ed talking about the demise of his relationship with Jillian, but what a great girl she is. Some other chick talking about how she thinks Ed would be good in bed. (ACK!) Ryan Park admitting what a dork he was for using his date with Ashley to talk about water heaters. Then more drinking and dancing.
And, most "dramatically", Frank talks about leaving the show when he realized he wanted his ex-girlfriend back instead of Ali. And how they got back together, but then broke up, so now maybe he wants Ali back. Then awkwardly hugging her.
All in all, the whole thing - as the attendees mentioned a few hundred times - was basically a casting call for Bachelor Pad 3. If you go to the reunion shows and act like a prude, forget it. If you use another contestant as a stripper pole, get crazy drunk, start a fight,
don't seem worried about STDs, leave with someone you barely know, etc., you've got a pretty good chance of getting an invite to Bachelor Pad. Yippee.
Okay, really, Ben's ladies...
Right off the bat, I have to mention that Jennifer's magenta hair is now red. Not a beautiful orange-y red or strawberry blonde... but actual red. Like an apple. Or a marker. Or some color that couldn't possibly exist in nature. I don't get it. If you're going to go that drastic, just go Katy Perry blue.
After Jamie declares that she was so glad Ben was the Bachelor (and we are forced to relive the awkward mouth-raping she put on Ben... just when we were finally able to sleep again without that nightmare), Chris starts recapping the Blakeley situation.
Now, I could repeat everything she said for you, but I have Knicks to stalk, so basically she just said that she was herself and she's sorry if that came off as offensive but that she didn't feel like she deserved some of the ugly statements made about her.
Somewhere amongst this, Samantha started yipping. First about Blakeley, then about Brittney.
Brittney, for her part, said that she left the show upon realizing that she had absolutely no attraction to Ben. PS: Brittney is my new favorite of the season.
Samantha took issue with this and continued yipping. Brittney, my new favorite, hilariously declared that Samantha was the chihuahua of the house. That she never stopped talking. Even Chris Harrison cracked up at this.
Next up, Shawntel came into the Hot Seat to discuss her ill-fated return. She said she didn't expect to be instant friends with anyone but that having the other girls attack her for her job and the size of her thighs was hurtful.
Fair enough.
Erika, the perpetrator of the "wide hips" comment, replied with "Well, I don't have tiny thighs, so..."
You know, for all the nastiness Courtney has vomited all over this season, Erika's comment was in a douchey league of its own. Why, once again, insult someone's thighs? Especially if you have "big thighs"? I mean, you don't see me mentioning how Monica's dress was too short and revealed her cellulite every time the camera zoomed in on the people in front of her, do you? Of course not. Because I have PLENTY of cellulite of my own. I just keep it covered. But Shawntel A) does not have big hips, thighs, or anything else, and B) Erika is mean.
In response to her famous face-contorting "WHO IS SHE?!" declaration by Elyse, she says she actually did know who Shawntel was but she was so taken aback to have her date interrupted that she didn't piece together that it was Shawntel or what was happening. Okay, fair enough.
Yes, fair enough is my theme for the night. Because, honestly, does anything said on this episode change your opinion about anyone you totally loved or totally hated? No. But for the people you were kind of meh about, it just gives them a chance to make a few good points or make a few bad points, right? So, "fair enough" is all I can muster.
Next up, Emily takes the Hot Seat. She says a negative piece was introduced to her relationship with Ben the moment she mentioned Courtney, but, in the end, she wouldn't want to be with someone who would say "Tread lightly. You don't know me as well as you think." instead of "I respect what you're saying. Thanks for coming to me with these concerns."
In response to the skinny dipping with Courtney, Emily says she felt it was disrespectful and that the skinny dipping just clouded his mind and made it all about sex instead of building relationships.
To which Chris Harrison replied "Well, you've finally figured out men. We can all go home now."
Fair enough. I completely agree with Emily. Getting nekkid with the first girl to drop trou was not a great way to keep your mind on relationship-building. But, I agree with Chris. For a lot of men, especially those inclined to come on this show, relationships probably come second to the topless chick in front of you.
Emily wraps up her thoughts by saying that, if Ben picked Courtney, then he's made his bed and now he can lie in it.
And he will lie in it. For however long it takes him to make mediocre lovin' to Courtney. And he'll continue to lie in it as often as she'll let him. Which won't be long.
Nicki's time in the Hot Seat was uneventful. She's the "still holding on" girl this season. She was blindsided, she still has feelings for him, but she's ok now. Blah blah.
KCB tells us she worried maybe she didn't say enough or do enough. And, obviously, she didn't. What could she have done differently? Been skankier and naked-er, obviously. Sorry, KCB. But,she adds that she got most of her answers when she "flew halfway around the world" to Switzerland. Ugh.
Finally, the girls begin the all-out trashing of Courtney.
Everyone says how mean she was, how she was Jekyll and Hyde around Ben, how she was clearly there to win, etc. The only one defending her was Casey S. Casey says Courtney really did have a crush on Ben even when she watched him on Ashley's season.
Elyse (?) says "Of course she did. He was on TV."
Raise your hand if you hollered "Amen!"
Emily continues that, even if it had been any other Joe Schmo up there, Courtney would have tried her darndest to win.
Finally, Courtney takes the Hot Seat. She begins by saying the way the girls reacted to her is fair and that she wishes she could have done so much differently. That she came into the house not wanting confrontation, but it just played out differently.
Blakeley says she wants to know what she ever did to warrant being called a stripper. Courtney replies "Nothing". That's when the fake tears begin.
Basically, everyone except Casey S. felt like Courtney only came to the WTA to repair her image. Nicki asks, if that wasn't the case, what was the turning point when Court realized she was wrong.
Courtney says it was when she was able to be out of the situation for a few days (hometown dates) and reflect on things.
Um, really? Because, at some points in my life, I've been intentionally mean to people. I knew I was doing it at the time. I did it anyway. TO BE MEAN. I didn't need a few days to reflect on it and realize I was being mean. I knew it already. Now, obviously, at some other point I felt bad about that and made amends. So if Courtney had said that, I'd totally be like "Yeah, I get that", but to say that you needed a few days to reflect and realize how terribly you'd acted? Unlikely. I don't buy it.
Also still not buying it? The bulk of the other ladies. Especially since Courtney's best "excuse" for her actions was that she was uncomfortable and didn't know how to handle the situation. Emily wisely responds that every single girl there was uncomfortable, but they chose to make friends and support each other. Courtney chose to lash out at the girls and spend the rest of the time in her room.
Courtney says she just wishes the girls could have gotten to know the real her. Um, well, I think they did. But, whatever. The girls roll their eyes as hard as I did. Then Court launches into a soliloquy about how sorry she is, from the bottom of her heart, and that this is the hardest things she's ever had to go through and she just hopes the girls can forgive her.
Emily again pipes up that, when she apologized to Courtney, Courtney says "I don't forgive and forget" but yet she's asking them to forgive her? Curious.
Blakeley tries to talk a little more to Courtney, but hits a wall. She then says "I'm trying to be nice to you and you won't even look at me." So, that pretty much sums up what I think of Courtney's apology.
In the end, she leaves the stage and the girls continue to gripe about her.
Fair enough.
Lastly, Ben comes on stage. He said absolutely nothing worth repeating. His answer to any questions about his motives began with "Well, in that moment..."
Seriously, nothing worth repeating. But, what can he say? It's pretty obvious to 98% of America that he picks Courtney. And 98% of America hates her. Anything he said that even kind of defended her would have resulted in a bum rush from the women.
The night wraps up with the infamous blooper reel we see every season. Tonight's highlights included Ben being attacked by a bird while out on a yacht, a cow crashing his picnic with Courtney, and lots and lots and lots of dorky dancing and falling down. Geesh. Even the highlight reel this season was a waste.
Also a waste? The 10 minutes spent on scenes from next week's finale. You know what? We're going to watch the finale. No one who cares enough to watch the Women Tell All is going to be like "Nah. I'm over it. Forget the finale." We're going to watch. We all strongly suspect Courtney wins and we will want to throw our beverage of choice at the TV, but we're going to watch. It's what we do. So do we really need an exhausting, long preview? No. Ugh.
So, that's the Women Tell All. Or, as I like to call it, the Women Tell (nothing at) All. Did we learn anything we didn't already know? No. Did they spend almost half the show attempting to humanize Courtney in an effort to soften the blow if/when Ben picks her next week? Yes. Did it work? No. All in all, I could have spent those two hours in the lobby trying to see a famous person. Instead, I drug a chair up to the TV and took notes, much to the shock of the housekeeper who came in for the turndown service. I can only imagine how crazy I must have looked. Thanks a lot, The Bachelor, thanks a lot. For nothing.
The only think that made it worth watching was the clip as the credits rolled. Chris referenced Jenna's insane meltdown and crazy comments, particularly the "we can share a tampon" comment she made to Monica. Monica, as a peace offering, brought out a (clean) tampon to give to Jenna.
Yes, seriously, that was the highlight of the night. I know, right?
I'm actually scheduling this to post on Monday night, before I've done my radio recap, but I'll try to come back and post the link... though I'll most likely just talk about my Knick-stalking and not lame ol' Ben. (UPDATE: The link to the radio recap is
HERE
See you next week, for what I'm sure will be a "I CAN'T BELIEVE HE PICKED THAT WRETCHED WOMAN!!!" gripe session. (Except, yes, I can believe it. Refer to her willingness to be naked. The end.)